Reading This Data

Judicial Performance Commission results indicate how JPR Commissioners voted, whether a judge “MEETS” Judicial Performance Standards based on survey information as well as all other information submitted by the public or the judge. Judicial Performance Surveys percentages show results of surveys completed by respondents based on the averaged results of the survey respondents who rated the judge “satisfactory” or better in combined Judicial Performance Standards categories.

Judicial Performance Standards include:

• Legal Ability: Decides cases based on applicable law, demonstrating competent legal analysis.

• Integrity: Free from personal bias. Administers justice fairly, ethically, and uniformly.

• Communication Skills: Issues prompt and understandable rulings and directions.

• Judicial Temperament: Dignified, courteous, and patient.

• Administrative Performance: Manages courtroom and office effectively. Issues rulings promptly and efficiently.

RESULTS OF THE COMMISSION’S VOTE ON THE PINAL COUNTY SUPERIOR COURT JUDGES
The following judges DO NOT MEET Judicial Performance Standards
NONE
The following judges MEET Judicial Performance Standards
Karl C. Eppich Joseph R. Georgini Henry G. Gooday, Jr.	Jason Holmberg Stephen F. McCarville

JUDGE	JPR Votes “Meets” Judicial Standards	JPR Votes “Does Not Meet” Judicial Standards	Did Not Vote	JPR Commission Member Did Not Vote on Self	Details Page
Karl C. Eppich	32	0	0	0	100
Joseph R. Georgini	32	0	0	0	100
Henry G. Gooday, Jr.	32	0	0	0	100
Jason Holmberg	32	0	0	0	100
Stephen F. McCarville	31	0	0	1	101